Introduction
Music education is a vital part of early childhood development. Historically, music was an integrated art form encompassing melody, poetry, and dance (Stamou, 2002). While these elements began to diverge around the fifth century BCE, music's power to shape human experience has persisted. Plato (428-347 BCE), for instance, believed that rhythm and harmony could profoundly influence the soul.
Piano lessons have been a mainstay of extracurricular education since the late 19th century. Fisher notes the prevalence of teaching within the musical profession, seeing that while some musicians become conductors or hold positions as organists and choirmasters, a vast majority also teach.
Doctor Sally Cathcart, in "The Social History of Piano Teaching" (2025), documents a rise in unqualified piano teachers during this period, charging low fees, sometimes as little as 3d (equivalent to £1.21 today). Lessons were often haphazard, relying on a collection of tutor books and technical exercises. John Curwen, in his teaching manual (2025), advocated for a progressive approach, suggesting that easier material should be studied first, followed by new concepts that build upon earlier learning. However, as Doctor Cathcart points out, any tutor books, and indeed teachers, often disregarded this principle, with notable exceptions. Mrs. Curwen even lamented the errors present in introductory lessons focusing on notation and rhythm. This low standard of piano teaching and poor-quality materials contributed to a low standard of piano playing and musicality. The next development of graded examinations and exam boards created a uniquely British system that provided structure, accountability, and standardized expectations.
While haphazard lessons may suit some students, and a one-size-fits-all tutor book approach may work for others, a music teacher who actively engages in continuous professional development and tailors their teaching to the individual student's needs offers a flexible, yet structured, learning experience. An interconnected program using a multitude of methods aligns with the principles of Rhizomatic learning (Crozier, 2011). Rhizomatic learning is a way of thinking about learning based on ideas described by Gilles Deleuze and Felix Guattari in a thousand plateaus.
Learning that is rhizomatic in nature is based on the ideas of Gilles Deleuze and Felix Guattari, which they explored in their work "A Thousand Plateaus." (Deleuze, 2025) In his blog, "Building a Better Rhizome" (2011), Crozier explores the question of "Why do we teach?" suggesting that the goal is for the student to surpass the teacher's knowledge. He argues that a fixed curriculum can encourage passivity, while teachers should instead create a context for student learning, fostering "not a series of remembered ideas, reproduced for testing, and quickly forgotten, but something flexible that is already integrated with the other things a learner knows."
This concept of lessons as a map inspired the development of the Triquetrae Music Programmes. Each level is envisioned as a field where students can explore, discover, and engage with various aspects of music. Within the Elementary program, each section provides a small map for that area. The path taken is a collaborative decision between the teacher (guide) and the student (explorer). Certain elements, such as producing a sound or understanding concepts like notes, duration, and tempo, are essential, just as a traveller knows not to pick certain flowers or swim in dangerous waters. Other aspects can be explored in different sequences. This approach marks the beginning of an adventure in music.
The Triquetrae Programme
This guide introduces the Triquetrae Elementary Programme, a novel approach to music education designed for young children. The program is built upon seven core components—Find, Create, Grow, Develop, Achieve, Explore, and Build—each targeting specific aspects of musical skill development. These components are further divided into sub-skills, such as articulation, composition, and listening, and are supported by suggested activities and materials. Structured across four progressive levels, the Triquetrae program aims to foster integrated musical growth and engagement.
The Triquetrae Music Programme is adaptable to both one-to-one tuition and classroom settings. TQ worksheets can be used in either context, the framework incorporates differentiation for diverse learning needs. Worksheets are categorised into five skill levels (suited for "all," "many," "most," "some," and "few" students), allowing educators to select components from each zone to meet the specific requirements of their students in each session.
The core resources for each zone have all the necessary materials for that area. Each zone is organized into twelve rows, breaking down each concept into small, manageable steps to ensure thorough understanding. While some students may grasp concepts quickly and not require every step or activity, others may receive help from a more comprehensive approach. This structure helps differentiation, enabling educators to select materials based on individual student needs within the Achieve Zone and other relevant areas. Materials are selected from each of the seven zones to best support student learning, with a primary skill named for each row, while recognizing the presence and development of other sub-skills.
The seven zones are intentionally arranged in the order of sharps in the key signature. This provides a clear educational framework for the presented information. It is important to note, however, that this arrangement does not dictate a rigid teaching sequence. The zones are interconnected, functioning much like the hexagonal cells of a honeycomb, allowing for flexible and integrated learning experiences.
Quiz
-
How did early music education contrast with its later developments, and what philosophical viewpoints supported its importance?
-
What issues plagued piano teaching in the late 19th century, and how did these issues affect the quality of musical education?
-
How did graded examinations and exam boards address the problems identified in 19th-century piano teaching?
-
What is Rhizomatic learning, and how does it relate to the philosophy behind the Triquetrae Music Programme?
-
How does the Triquetrae Elementary Programme conceptualize the role of the teacher and student in the learning process?
-
Name the seven core components of the Triquetrae Elementary Programme and briefly explain their purpose.
-
How does the Triquetrae Music Programme accommodate diverse learning needs in both one-to-one and classroom settings?
-
Describe the organizational structure of each zone within the Triquetrae Music Programme regarding steps and concept breakdown.
-
What is the significance of the "Achieve Zone" and how does it relate to differentiation within the Triquetrae Music Programme?
-
Explain the purpose of arranging the seven zones in the order of sharps in the key signature, and what this arrangement does not dictate.
Essay Questions
-
Analyze the historical evolution of music education from an integrated art form to the challenges of 19th-century piano teaching. Discuss how these historical developments influenced the need for structured music programmes like Triquetrae.
-
Evaluate the principles of Rhizomatic learning as described in the source and discuss how the Triquetrae Music Programme exemplifies these principles in its design and implementation.
-
Compare and contrast the "haphazard lessons" of 19th-century piano teaching with the structured yet flexible approach of the Triquetrae Elementary Programme. What specific elements of Triquetrae aim to address the shortcomings of earlier methods?
-
Discuss the role of differentiation in the Triquetrae Music Programme. Explain how the programme’s structure, including skill-level categorization and zone organization, supports individualized learning in diverse settings.
-
Examine the "teacher as guide, student as explorer" metaphor in the context of the Triquetrae Music Programme. How does this collaborative approach foster deeper engagement and a more adventurous learning experience for students?
Glossary of Key Terms
-
Rhizomatic Learning: A concept of learning inspired by Gilles Deleuze and Felix Guattari's work "A Thousand Plateaus," emphasizing a non-linear, interconnected, and flexible approach to knowledge acquisition where learning paths are not fixed and students can surpass teachers' knowledge.
-
Triquetrae Music Programme: A novel approach to music education, particularly the Elementary Programme, designed for young children, built upon seven core components and adaptable to various learning settings.
-
Elementary Programme: The introductory level of the Triquetrae Music Programme, designed for young children, focusing on foundational musical skill development across seven core components.
-
Seven Core Components (Triquetrae): The foundational elements of the Triquetrae Elementary Programme: Find, Create, Grow, Develop, Achieve, Explore, and Build, each targeting specific aspects of musical skill.
-
TQ Worksheets: Differentiated learning materials used within the Triquetrae Music Programme, categorized into five skill levels ("all," "many," "most," "some," and "few") to cater to diverse student needs.
-
Graded Examinations: A system, particularly prominent in Britain, that provides structure, accountability, and standardized expectations for musical education through progressive assessments.
-
John Curwen: An advocate for a progressive approach to music teaching, suggesting that easier material should be studied first, followed by new concepts that build upon earlier learning.
-
Doctor Sally Cathcart: Author of "The Social History of Piano Teaching" (2025), who documented the rise of unqualified piano teachers and the low standards of piano teaching in the late 19th century.
-
Deleuze and Guattari: Philosophers who explored the ideas of rhizomatic learning in their work "A Thousand Plateaus," influencing the conceptual framework of the Triquetrae Music Programme.
-
Crozier: Author of the blog "Building a Better Rhizome" (2011), who explores the question "Why do we teach?" and argues against fixed curricula, advocating for teachers to create a context for student learning.